The burgeoning body of research in Behavioral Economics esentially maligns the traditional assumption of economists about the rationality of human behavior. The basic tenets of traditional Economics on the rationality assumption are being criticized because they are simply not being observed in real life. For example, economists believe that humans are homo economicus, a rational, selfish, calculating, and insensitive being. His end goal is the pursuit of his own happiness or well-being. Everything he does is about and for himself only. This is basically how behavioral economists view the traditional economist's homo economicus.
This interesting new branch of economics is obviously highly influenced by recent research in the field of psychology. Many social experiments have been done that question the assumption of rationality. Some even came up with the notion of 'bounded rationality', to please both ends of the spectrum. It means that humans are rational, but only to the extent of the information available to him. But even if a vast of information is laid out in front of him, there are times that humans still choose the less optimal choice. These mistakes in the decision making of humans lead to the theory that humans are in fact irrational. Some say this is not a bad thing, because humans' irrationality is predictable anyway, that on average, we act the way we do, just because. For no reason at all, we just behave against the predictions of a traditional economic models where we are supposed to be maximizing our utility. Classic examples of attacks against the rationality assumption are the results of Ultimatum games actually played by people with real money. With the rationality assumption, the first player will not give even a dime to the second player, and that ends the game. In practice, first players do give even more than half of what they have to the second player, with a mere hope that the second player will reciprocate their kindness by giving back a doubled amount of the initial payout. In some settings, this game was played with anonymity to guarantee that the first player is not influenced by whoever is the second player.
On the other hand, there are still many mighty economists who defend the very important assumption of rationality. This assumption is quintessential to the field of Economics because most of the foundations of this field use optimization techniques which operate only under the rationality assumption. It is analogous to a doctrine of a certain religion. Once disproved, that religion will be branded as a fraud or cease to exist. These defenders say that a homo economicus is not necessarily selfish and insensitive. A person is still maximizing his utility even if he sacrifices some of his resources for the benefit of others (altruism), if the weight he puts on the utility of others is greater than the value he attributes to his loss. To an outsider, this might seem that he is choosing the less optimal choice, but to the person himself, he actually feels more than satisfied.
I am clearly very interested in this brewing debate. Both ends have valid arguments and have a collection of well-grounded experiments to prove their points. But where do I stand?
Presently, I find myself still clinging to the rationality assumption. I think, with just a little tweak in the model, the claims of behavioral theorists on the irrationality of human behavior might be answered. For instance, altruism which was believed to be a form of irrationality, can be proven to be in fact a rational behavior. It's just a matter of perspective and the weight we attribute to the things that affect us. A first player in an Ultimatum game may have given some of his resources, and expecting nothing in return, because he came from a community of very generous people. His utility function factors in how greatly he values giving. It does not necessarily mean that this is an irrational behavior. This might sound hedonistic, but my mind keeps focusing on the idea that man truly just wants to be happy, or to be a utility-maximizer. It does not necessarily imply selfishness in a sense that harms other people. People's decisions are affected by their value systems, which essentially are the factors that determine their happiness. Value systems differ vastly among different groups of people, but one cannot say that the other is irrational just because their goals don't meet. Supporters of same-sex marriage is as rational as fighters of religious freedom. Both want an end that will ultimately give them satisfaction. But this debate may never end and I am afraid economics is not the appropriate stage to determine who will win. To say that a behavior is irrational might be misleading. It could be that an outsider just can not see the other underlying factors that made that person behave in a seemingly irrational way. Those latent factors may even be hiding in the subconscious mind of the actor. It could be that when those unobserved factors are taken into account, the person is actually being rational about his behavior.
Even though it's an in thing to be involved in experimental or behavioral economics, I am still a believer of a homo economicus, but not that cold-hearted and selfish one which the attackers of rationality assumption believe him to be. Maybe by tweaking slightly some parts of widely criticized models of economic behavior and incorporating a factor such as the gap in value system of individuals, it may be shown that the rationality assumption still holds true even with the presence of the apparently irrational behaviors that are observed in their social experiments.
No comments:
Post a Comment